‘Dr Horror earned 200% profit per transplant’

Sunday, February 10, 2008
http://sify.com/news/fullstory.php?id=14602228

Before he was caught, handcuffed and thrown into a police cell, Indian kidney racket kingpin Amit Kumar Raut lived life king size thanks to the nearly 200 per cent profit he gained per illegal transplant, according to his reported admission to Nepal Police.

He also denied having any links with the underworld or doing anything illegal.

"I am a doctor by profession," the unshaken 43-year-old, who holds just a diploma in ayurveda and is not a qualified doctor, told the police after being arrested from a holiday resort in south Nepal on Thursday.

"I did people a service (through the transplants). I ran the Star Max Life Care Hospital in Gurgaon in India's Haryana State," Amit Kumar told police in his statement, a news report said on Saturday.

"Transplanting kidneys is my main business. I have been doing this for 15 years."

According to the Nepali tabloid Naya Patrika, Amit Kumar told the Metropolitan Police's crime division, who began interrogating him afresh on Friday, that patients from the US, Canada and European countries used to come to his clinic for transplants.

"I have conducted about 3,000 transplants for patients from these countries," Amit Kumar reportedly told the police.

He said there were legal complications about kidney transplants. Several States had tight laws preventing such acts.

"In Haryana, the laws are slightly more lenient, which is why I opened my hospital there," he reportedly said.

Amit Kumar is said to have told police that he used to charge per kidney recipient Rs 3,00,000-4,00,000 for a transplant.

"The poor and unemployed in India are interested in donating their kidneys," the tabloid quoted him as saying to the police. "I used to pay the donors Rs 25,000 to Rs 100,000."

However, Amit Kumar insisted that he had not done anything wrong.

"I did not force anyone to donate their kidneys," he said. "I did not dupe anyone. The kidneys were extracted with the consent of the donors. Therefore, it was not a crime."

"The sellers were poor Indians and buyers rich foreigners. I acted as the go-between and did people a service. I took money only after offering my services, it can't be construed as robbery."

Amit Kumar rejected the allegations that he had links with the underworld.

"I did not take the help of the underworld for my transplant operations," the father of two said.

"At times I have also worked without profit to transplant poor and unemployed donors' kidneys."

Kumar blamed the Indian media for his plight.

"After the media targeted me, the Moradabad authorities filed a case against me in Uttar Pardesh state," he alleged.

Asked why he was on the run if he had not done anything wrong, Amit Kumar said he was not running away but trying to defend himself.

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 14.9.2007

Friday, September 14, 2007
RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 14.9.2007



S.N

Name of the Hospital

Name of the Patient

Name of the Donor

Approved Or Not Approved

Reason for Not Approved

1

Coimbatore Kidney Center Coimbatore

Mr.R.Thirumani

Mrs.Kousal Rani

Approved

----------

2

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr .Kamakhya Patowari

Mr. Swapan Roy

Approved

----------

3

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.K.K.Sathyavan

Mr.T.V.Sudheer

Approved

----------

4

MIOT Hospital Chennai

Mr.Iyamuremye Octavien

Mr.Hashakimana Jacaues

Approved

----------

5

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mrs.Vijayalakshmi

Mrs.Suguna

Not Approved

The identity with reference to residential address and photograph are not clearly established.

Donor and her spouse are ignorant about the nature of organ donation.

6

Coimbatore Kidney Center Coimbatore

Ms.Virundha Nair

Mrs.M.Poongodi

Not Approved

The genuiness of the person who has attested the photograph is not proved.

The donor and her spouse are contradicting their statement .

The consequences and the nature of organ donation are not fully known.

7

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mrs.Pratima Shou

Mr.Biswambhar Chakraborty

Approved

----------

8

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mr.Consain

Mrs.Mary

Not Approved

No Objection Certificate from the Srilankan Embassy is not in proper format.



Chairman

Authorisation Committee

Chennai


To

Coimbatore Kidney Center

738-B Puliakulam Centre

Coimbatore-641 045



Kovai Medical Center And Hospital

Post Box.No.3209

Avanashi Road

Coimbatore 641 014


Chennai Kaliappa Hospital

52,Second Main Road,

Raja Annamalai Puram

Chennai 600 028


MIOT Hospitals

4/112 Mount Poonamalee Road

Manapakkam

Chennai.600 080

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 7.9.2007

Friday, September 7, 2007
RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 7.9.2007



S.N

Name of the Hospital

Name of the Patient

Name of the Donor

Result

Remarks

1

Govt.Stanley Hospital,Chennai

Mr.Shabutheen

Mrs.Nazim Begum

Approved

----------------

2

SHIFA Hospital

Tirunelveli Junction

Mr.Stalin

Mrs.Saroja

Approved

----------------

3

Apollo Hospital

Chennai

Mr.Ram Chandra Chakraborty

Mr.Shankar Nasker

Approved

----------------

4

Apollo Hospital

Chennai

Ms.S.Ash Rena Mani

Mr.T.Dhanakotti Gopal Naidu

Approved

----------------


Chairman

Authorisation Committee

Chennai


To:

Apollo Hospital

21,Greams Lane ,Off Greams Road

Chennai.6


Dr.R.VijayakumarM.D.,D.M..,

Proffessor and Head

Department of Nephrology

Govt.Stanley Hospital,Chennai

Through The Dean

Govt.Stanley Hospital,Chennai


SHIFA Hospital

82 Kailasapuram Middle Street

Tirunelveli Junction

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 31.8.2007

Friday, August 31, 2007
RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 31.8.2007


S.N

Name of the Hospital

Name of the Patient

Name of the Donor

Result

Reason for not Approved

1

Apollo Speciality Hospital, Madurai

Mr.Pandy

Mr.S.P.Kanagaraj

Approved

----------------

2

Coimbatore Kidney Center,Coimbatore

Mr.K.Ramasamy

Mr.M.Sekar

Approved

----------------

3

Coimbatore Kidney Center,Coimbatore

Mr.Mohammed Asraf

Mrs.T.Jaya

Approved

----------------

4

Coimbatore Kidney Center,Coimbatore

Mr.S.Kalimuthu

Mr.A.Murugan

Approved

----------------

5

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mrs.Rabia Maheta

Mr.Goutam Mallick

Not Approved

As the affidavits in the local language and English are not sworn and attested by the Magistrate of their State/Locality.

6

Sri Ramakrishna Hospital,

Coimbatore

Mrs.I.Rathinam

Mr.Senthilkumar

Absent

--------------

7

Kovai Medical Center,Coimbatore

Mr.Anthony Cheran Momin

Mr.Krishna Kalita

Approved

----------------

8

Madras Institute of Nephrology Vijaya Hospital,Chennai`

Mr.Rubi Adhikary

Mrs.Anjali Roy

Not Approved

As the affidavits in the local language and English are not sworn and attested by the Magistrate.

Chairman

Authorisation Committee

Chennai


To:

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital

52,Second Main Road,

Raja Annamalai Puram

Chennai 600 028


Coimbatore Kidney Center

738-B Puliakulam Centre

Coimbatore-641 045


Kovai Medical Center And Hospital

Post Box.No.3209

Avanashi Road

Coimbatore 641 014


Madras Institute of Nephrology

Vijaya Hospital

Vijaya Gardens

NSK Salai

Chennai-26


Sri Ramakrishna Hospital

395 Sarojini Naidu Road

Sidhapudur

Coimbatore 641 004


Apollo Speciality Hospital

Lake View Road

K.K.Nagar

Madurai 625 020

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 24.8.2007

Friday, August 24, 2007
RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 24.8.2007


S.N

Name of the Hospital

Name of the Patient

Name of the Donor

Result

Reason for Not Approved

1

Apollo Hospital

Chennai

Ms.S.Ash Rena Mani

Mr.T.Dhanakotti Gopal Naidu

Not Approved

As the recipient is a Foreign National and the relationship with the donor (Indian National) is not clearly certified by the competent authority and the photo I.D proof of the donor’s spouse is not available.

2

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.V.P.Abooty

Mr.Abdul Rahman

Approved

----------

3

Coimbatore Kidney Center Coimbatore

Mr.Farook

Mrs.Palaniammal

Approved

----------

4

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mr.Consain

Mrs.Mary

Not Approved

The proof of nationality of the donor and NOC from the Srilanka Embassy in the proper format have to be produced

5

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mrs.Pratima Shou

Mr.Biswambhar Chakraborty

Not Approved

As the donor’s spouse is not available for counseling by the authorization committee .

6

Madras Medical Mission,Chennai

Mr.Pradeep Doss

Mrs.Aleyamma

Absent



--------------

7

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.Bikasjyoti Chowdhury

Mr.Subhash Kalita

Approved

----------

8

Coimbatore Kidney Center Coimbatore

Ms.Virundha Nair

Mrs.M.Poongodi

Not Approved

The consequences and nature of the organ donation is not know to the donor.

The Photo ID from the Revenue authority does not bear the signature of the competent authority .

9

PSG Hospital

Coimbatore

Mr.Vadivel

Mr.Vairavel

Approved

----------


Chairman

Authorisation Committee

Chennai


To:

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital

52,Second Main Road,

Raja Annamalai Puram

Chennai 600 028


Kovai Medical Center And Hospital

Post Box.No.3209

Avanashi Road

Coimbatore 641 014

Apollo Hospital

21,Greams Lane ,Off Greams Road

Chennai.6


PSG Hospitals

Avinashi Road

Peelamedu

Coimbatore 641 004


Madras Medical Mission

4-A Dr.J.Jayalalitha Nagar,

Mogappair

Chennai 600 037


Coimbatore Kidney Center

738-B Puliakulam Centre

Coimbatore-641 045

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 17.8.2007

Friday, August 17, 2007
RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 17.8.2007


S.N

Name of the Hospital

Name of the Patient

Name of the Donor

Result

Remarks

1

Apollo Hospital

Chennai

Mr.Ramachandra Chakraborthy

Mr.Shankar Nasker

Not Approved

The Death Certificate of the donor’s parents from the competent authority is not available

2

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.Sabharam Gayan

Mr.Rameswar Bora

Approved

---------------

3

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.Gnanasekaran

Mrs.Dhanalakshmi

Approved

---------------

4

PSG Hospital Coimbatore

Mr.Vadivel

Mr.Vairavel

Absent

---------------

5

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mr.Md.Farmuj Ali

Mr.Yakub Ali

Approved

---------------

6

Christian Medical College,Vellore

Mr.Lalarenjam Moren Singh

Ms.Keisam Nandrarawz Devi

Approved

---------------


Chairman

Authorisation Committee

Chennai



To:

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital

52,Second Main Road,

Raja Annamalai Puram

Chennai 600 028


Kovai Medical Center And Hospital

Post Box.No.3209

Avanashi Road

Coimbatore 641 014


Christian Medical College

IDA Scudder Road

Vellore 632 004

Apollo Hospital

21,Greams Lane ,Off Greams Road

Chennai.6


PSG Hospitals

Avinashi Road

Peelamedu

Coimbatore 641 004

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 17.8.2007

RESULT OF THE AUTHORISATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 17.8.2007


S.N

Name of the Hospital

Name of the Patient

Name of the Donor

Result

Remarks

1

Apollo Hospital

Chennai

Mr.Ramachandra Chakraborthy

Mr.Shankar Nasker

Not Approved

The Death Certificate of the donor’s parents from the competent authority is not available

2

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.Sabharam Gayan

Mr.Rameswar Bora

Approved

---------------

3

Kovai Medical Center Coimbatore

Mr.Gnanasekaran

Mrs.Dhanalakshmi

Approved

---------------

4

PSG Hospital Coimbatore

Mr.Vadivel

Mr.Vairavel

Absent

---------------

5

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital,Chennai

Mr.Md.Farmuj Ali

Mr.Yakub Ali

Approved

---------------

6

Christian Medical College,Vellore

Mr.Lalarenjam Moren Singh

Ms.Keisam Nandrarawz Devi

Approved

---------------


Chairman

Authorisation Committee

Chennai



To:

Chennai Kaliappa Hospital

52,Second Main Road,

Raja Annamalai Puram

Chennai 600 028


Kovai Medical Center And Hospital

Post Box.No.3209

Avanashi Road

Coimbatore 641 014


Christian Medical College

IDA Scudder Road

Vellore 632 004

Apollo Hospital

21,Greams Lane ,Off Greams Road

Chennai.6


PSG Hospitals

Avinashi Road

Peelamedu

Coimbatore 641 004